Polar Plunge Costume Ideas: What to Wear Into Freezing Water

Costumepedia earns a commission if you buy through links on this page. It doesn’t change what you pay. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Running into freezing water on purpose is a little ridiculous. That’s the whole point. And if you’re going to do something ridiculous, you might as well do it dressed as a Viking.

Polar plunges happen on New Year’s Day all over the country, and charity plunges run from January through March. Brooklyn’s Coney Island Polar Bear Club has been doing it since 1903.

The catch is that most costumes are terrible in water. Here’s what actually works, what to wear under it, and the gear that matters more than the costume.

Jump to a Costume

  1. Viking
  2. Baby New Year
  3. Superhero
  4. Mermaid
  5. Toga
  6. Santa Claus
  7. Pirate
  8. 80s Neon
  9. Penguin Team

1. Viking

Illustration of a Viking costume: a bearded man in a long belted wool tunic in rust and dark green with woven trim, a faux-fur cape over the shoulders, leg wraps, leather boots, a round painted wooden shield, a plain rounded iron helmet with no horns.

The unofficial uniform of the polar plunge. A Viking looks tough charging into icy water, and the horned helmet survives a dunk.

How to do it: Swimsuit or rash guard underneath, a faux-fur vest that you can toss on shore, a plastic horned helmet and a foam axe. Fake fur gets heavy wet, so wear it for photos and drop it before you go in.

Worth buying: a plastic Viking helmet.

2. Baby New Year

Illustration of a Baby New Year costume: a smiling toddler in a white onesie and diaper cover with a tiny black top hat and a gold sash, holding a party noisemaker.

Perfect for a January 1 plunge, and funny for grown adults. Baby New Year is basically already dressed for the water.

How to do it: White swim trunks or a white swimsuit, a mini top hat on an elastic strap and a sash with the new year. Pin the sash on so it doesn’t float away.

Worth buying: a mini top hat.

3. Superhero

Illustration of an original superhero costume: a person in a deep teal bodysuit with gold boots, gold gloves and a gold belt, a knee-length gold cape, a simple teal eye mask, and a gold lightning-bolt emblem on the chest, hands on hips.

Bright, fun and made of fabric that dries fast. A superhero with a short cape looks great running in.

How to do it: A colored rash guard or swimsuit with a felt emblem safety-pinned on, an eye mask and a short Velcro cape. Long capes tangle around your legs in the water.

Worth buying: a superhero cape.

4. Mermaid

Illustration of a mermaid costume: a woman in a fitted teal and purple sequin fishtail skirt that flares at the ankles into a fin, a seashell top over a fitted nude tank top, long loose wavy hair with small shells and pearls clipped in, family-friendly.

Literally made for the water. A mermaid is a swimsuit top and a sparkly wrap skirt.

How to do it: Sequin or scale-print swimsuit, a shimmery wrap skirt you can drop at the shoreline, a shell crown and wavy hair. Skip the tail you have to hop in.

Worth buying: a mermaid scale swimsuit.

5. Toga

Illustration of a toga costume: a man in a white sheet toga draped over one shoulder with a gold cord at the waist, a gold laurel wreath, an arm cuff and sandals, holding a scroll.

The bedsheet classic. A toga works because a cheap white sheet is no loss if it gets ruined.

How to do it: Wear a swimsuit underneath, wrap a white flat sheet and pin it well, and add a plastic gold laurel wreath. Expect the sheet to cling and drag once it’s wet.

Worth buying: a gold laurel wreath.

6. Santa Claus

Illustration of a classic Santa Claus costume: a jolly man in a plush red velvet suit with thick white fur trim, a wide black belt with a gold buckle, black boots, a full soft white beard and mustache, a red hat with a white pom-pom, round wire glasses, white gloves, rosy cheeks.

A holiday plunge favorite. A swim-ready Santa is red trunks, a beard and a hat.

How to do it: Red swim trunks or a red swimsuit, a Santa hat with a chin strap, and a cheap synthetic beard you don’t mind soaking. Leave the velvet suit on shore.

Worth buying: a Santa hat with a chin strap.

7. Pirate

Illustration of a pirate costume: a man in a loose cream shirt with billowy sleeves, a brown vest, a red waist sash, dark breeches tucked into tall boots, a black tricorn hat over a bandana, a cutlass at his hip, a gold hoop earring.

Walking the plank is the joke that writes itself. A pirate is easy to build from swimwear.

How to do it: Striped rash guard or swimsuit, a red bandana, an eye patch and a foam sword. Bandanas stay put in the water far better than hats.

Worth buying: a pirate bandana and eye patch set.

8. 80s Neon

Illustration of a 1980s aerobics costume: a woman in a neon pink leotard over shiny tights, bright leg warmers, a sweatband, a side ponytail with a scrunchie, white high-top sneakers.

Loud colors pop in winter photos. An 80s look is just neon swimwear and accessories.

How to do it: Neon swimsuit or trunks, a sweatband, wristbands and big sunglasses with a strap. Swap leg warmers for neon water socks.

Worth buying: neon water socks.

9. Penguin Team

Plunging with a group? Matching penguin looks get the best photos. It’s just black and white swimwear and orange water shoes for feet.

How to do it: Black swimsuit or rash guard with a white felt belly patch pinned on, an orange beak on a headband and orange water shoes. Waddle in for maximum effect.

Worth buying: orange water shoes.

What to Wear Under a Costume and What to Bring

Water shoes are not optional. Beaches and lake bottoms in winter hide rocks, shells and ice, and you won’t feel your feet. Neoprene socks or water shoes protect them and keep a little warmth in.

Wear a swimsuit or rash guard as your base, and keep the costume light. Anything heavy, furry or long gets waterlogged and pulls on you. Cotton is the worst; it stays cold and wet.

Have your dry kit ready before you go in: a towel, a changing robe or poncho, a warm hat, dry socks and slip-on shoes. Your hands won’t work well afterward, so skip anything with small buttons or laces.

Keep it short and never plunge alone. Cold water can make you gasp and breathe fast for the first minute, so walk in, don’t dive, and get out. If you have a heart condition or high blood pressure, talk to your doctor first.

Planning a New Year’s plunge? See our New Year’s Eve collection, or browse the full costume encyclopedia from A to Z.

Polar Plunge FAQ

What do you wear to a polar plunge?

A swimsuit or rash guard, water shoes or neoprene socks, and a light costume on top. Have a towel, a changing robe and warm dry clothes waiting on shore.

Should I wear shoes for a polar plunge?

Yes. Water shoes or neoprene socks protect your feet from rocks and ice, since cold water numbs them quickly.

What’s the best costume for a polar plunge?

Something light that works wet, like a Viking helmet, a superhero cape, a mermaid swimsuit or Baby New Year on January 1.

How long do you stay in at a polar plunge?

Most people are in and out in under a minute. Walk in, dunk if you want, and get out.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *