Thanksgiving Play Costumes for Kids: 9 Easy Ideas You Can Make in a Night
Costumepedia earns a commission if you buy through links on this page. It doesn’t change what you pay. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
The note comes home in the backpack on a Tuesday. Your kid is “Turkey #3” in the Thanksgiving play, and the play is Friday.
Relax. Every costume here comes together in one evening, mostly from clothes, felt and paper you already have. They’re comfortable enough for a squirmy six-year-old to wear through a whole performance, and none of them need a sewing machine.
Teachers, there’s a section at the bottom on keeping the play respectful, since that’s the question we hear most.
Jump to a Costume
1. Turkey
Every Thanksgiving play has a flock of them. A turkey is a brown shirt and a big paper tail.
How to do it: Brown shirt and leggings, a fan of tail feathers cut from colored paper or felt and glued to a paper plate pinned to the back, and a headband with a beak and a red wattle. Handprint feathers in paint are a classic class craft.
Worth buying: a kids’ turkey headband.
2. Pilgrim
The most common speaking role. A pilgrim costume is black, white and a hat.
How to do it: Girls: a dark dress or skirt, a white apron and a white bonnet or collar from a pillowcase. Boys: black pants and shirt, a white paper collar and a black paper buckle hat. Cut paper buckles for the shoes.
Worth buying: a kids’ pilgrim hat and collar set.
3. Pumpkin
Perfect for the littlest kids. A pumpkin is an orange shirt and a green stem.
How to do it: Orange shirt or sweatshirt with black felt or green leaves pinned on, green leggings, and a beanie with a green felt stem and curly pipe-cleaner vine.
Worth buying: a pumpkin stem hat.
4. Ear of Corn
Kids love this one, and it’s easy to spot on stage. An ear of corn needs pom-poms and felt.
How to do it: Yellow shirt with rows of yellow pom-poms glued on, green felt husk leaves safety-pinned at the shoulders, and a yarn tassel headband.
Worth buying: a bag of yellow pom-poms.
5. Cornucopia
A clever pick for a narrator or a kid who wants something different. The cornucopia is the horn of plenty, worn as a hat.
How to do it: A brown paper or wicker cone worn as a tall hat, with foam fruit, gourds and wheat glued so they spill out the front. Brown clothes underneath.
Worth buying: a bag of craft fruit and gourds.
6. Pumpkin Pie
Funny and sweet for a food-themed play. A pumpkin pie is orange on top and tan below.
How to do it: Orange shirt, tan pants or skirt for the crust, and a white puffy headband or cotton-ball hat for whipped cream. A paper plate with a pie slice drawn on makes a great prop.
Worth buying: white tulle for a whipped cream hat.
7. Scarecrow
Great for a harvest or farm scene. A scarecrow is plaid, patches and straw.
How to do it: Plaid shirt, jeans with felt patches, raffia straw sticking out of the cuffs and collar, a floppy hat and a little face paint on the nose and cheeks.
Worth buying: a bundle of craft raffia.
8. Farmer
An easy pick for kids who’d rather not wear anything silly. A farmer is overalls and a straw hat.
How to do it: Overalls or jeans, a plaid shirt, a red bandana and a straw hat. Carry a small basket of fake vegetables.
Worth buying: a kids’ straw hat.
9. The Mayflower
Need a group project or a big prop? Two or three kids can “be” the Mayflower by standing inside a painted cardboard ship.
How to do it: A long cardboard box painted brown, cut into a boat shape with shoulder straps from ribbon, and a sail on a dowel. Kids wear pilgrim clothes inside it.
Worth buying: large cardboard boxes.
Keeping a Thanksgiving Play Respectful
Skip costume-store headdresses, war paint and “Indian” costumes. They’re stereotypes, and many schools have banned them for good reason. Food, harvest, animal and pilgrim roles give every kid a part without the problem.
If your play tells the story of the 1621 harvest, the Wampanoag people were central to it. Plimoth Patuxet Museums offers free materials for teachers that tell that part of the story accurately, and it’s worth reading before you assign roles.
Keep costumes stage-friendly. Nothing that covers the face, nothing kids have to hold for the whole show, and nothing that rustles so loudly it drowns out the lines.
See every costume in our Thanksgiving collection, or browse the full costume encyclopedia from A to Z.
Thanksgiving Play Costume FAQ
What are easy Thanksgiving play costumes for kids?
A turkey, a pilgrim, a pumpkin, an ear of corn or a pumpkin pie. Each can be made in a night from clothes, felt and paper.
How do I make a turkey costume for a school play?
Wear brown, pin a paper-plate tail with colored paper feathers to the back, and add a headband with a beak and red wattle.
How do I make a pilgrim costume from things at home?
Wear dark clothes with a white apron or paper collar, and make a black paper hat with a buckle or a white bonnet from a pillowcase.
Should kids dress as Native Americans for a Thanksgiving play?
No. Costume headdresses and face paint are stereotypes. Food, harvest and animal roles work better, and teachers can tell the Wampanoag story accurately using museum resources.
Free: The Last-Minute Costume Cheat Sheet
Ten costumes you can make tonight, mostly from your own closet. One page, printable, plus a short email before each costume season. No spam.














